I picked Pink Ballerina #17 and Emerald Green #19 which I think is very far from a true emerald green but still it's a pretty color.  Both are not glittery.  They are actually very matte for an eyeliner.

Since it's like a crayon a very slim crayon that is that means you can sharpen it.

Pink Ballerina is a very peachy color while Emerald Green is more of a teal than green.

I have to say this eyeliner by Holika Holika is super pigmented.  Good color payoff indeed.

You don't have to apply to much pressure because it glides smoothly on skin.  It's not patchy as well.  Putting on primer or moisturizer prior can also help especially for people who have dry skin.

About the waterproof test I tried to rub it and it didn't budge.  I also tried doing the "water splash" test and it didn't smear.  Though when I rubbed it with water it eventually smudged but not that easily.  Net I'd say it stayed in place all day err day.  :P

Full review on: http://chixylove.blogspot.com/2014/10/make-up-and-hair-holika-holika-jewel.html