I have very oily eyelids, so even though many brands claims to be waterproof it still smudges like panda on my eyes. I only found one brand that worked for my eyes, but I ran out of the liquid eyeliner and decided to try this eyeliner from MACQUEEN.
I really love this eyeliner, it is indeed water and oilproof and doesn't budge at all. I also like that the color is pigmented (I have both in black and brown), and the tip is easy to work with. i would definitely re-purchase this product again.