I am giving this lotion 5 stars because it does its job!  It hydrates my skin and it did not break me out.   My only grief is with the container.  I am not sure if they are made that way or if mine is defective but I do not like the cap (the white area at the top).  Once it has been opened, there is no way to close it.  Most bottles have a mechanism where you are able to turn the cap to the left and it locks and then to the right and it unlocks. This does not have that, which could make it a problem if traveling.  It may not be enough hydration for the winter months either but they have a cream, which I intend to try.  This is not a negative, clearly, as we all know that a lotion is lighter and provides a different type of moisture than a cream.  For a lotion, I find it very hydrating with only 2-3 pumps for the entire face.  Keep up the good work, Ciracle!  I am enjoying your products so far!