Color

Super pretty!  I can't stress enough how much I love this color on my lips!

It's not as intense as my other tint but it's still pigmented.  If Delight Tony Tint is 10 in terms of color payoff Pudding Tint is 6.  To match the first one's opaqueness we would need about 2 to 3 layers of this.  But then again I may be comparing an apple to a banana because the formula is different.  

Nevertheless if we are talking about just the color I'll give it a 10 because it could pass as one of the perfect orchid shade for me.  

Packaging

It pretty much reminds me of Benefit's Lollitint not just because of the name but also the nail-polish like bottle and the color too.  The texture looks very similar as well.  I don't have one and I haven't seen it personally so I'm not 100% sure and I can't further give details on the comparison.  I just saw some photos.  

It has this common doe-foot applicator - not slanted and the wand is very short compared to others.  No complaints though because you can still do gradient lip look easily.

I just don't like the idea of using a non-transparent packaging because I don't see how much product is left.  I also feel that the tip is not hitting the very bottom of the bottle.  No biggie at this point but maybe when the amount gets very little it will be difficult for me to consume the product entirely.  :)

Finish

Even though it's not water-based I think the finish is just the same.  It also looks very natural.  Difference is this one takes longer time to dry so it would appear glossy at first.

Application

t's easy to control and blend even without using your fingers.  The wand is in good quality too.

One thing to note though is that you may have to wait for it to dry completely to see the true color.  As it sets it becomes more saturated.  based on my experience I always apply 2 layers if I want a full lip color.  When I first tried this I ended up putting on more and more product because I couldn't see the intensity that I wanted.  So the technique is to let it sink in first because the first layer would look a bit sheer.

Texture

I love watery lip tints but I love this creamy pudding-like consistency even more!  It's not very thick and it feels oh so good on the lips.

Not to mention the adorable scent (and taste).  It's so addicting!

Formula

I start to notice the dehydrating effect after 5 hours.  According to the description online it contains argan oil to moisturize the lips.  Not bad!

Tints like this one tends to cling better when applied on bare lips or cheeks.  However it doesn't mean that we need to skip lip balm or even our face makeup.

As a cheek tint I find it not effective.  See the "sharp stain"?  It's because I didn't blend it after 5 seconds.  It's also hard to make the color pop so you'd need to apply a generous amount.  

Longevity

Net it lasts throughout the day.  Oh baby I'm impressed!  The color fades a little bit but lasting power is still great.  No need to re-apply multiple times.  It doesn't transfer on things easily as well.