I brought the volume one and it definitely does its job in making my lashes appear to have more volume. This have been my go-to mascara ever since I got it because it doesn't smudge or clump up my lashes. It also appears very natural in my opinion. The only bad thing I could say about this product is that it has a lot of fall outs. Once it dries, I could see a lot of fall outs on my cheek area but it doesn't really bother since it's not that noticeable and could easily be remove by brushing it off with powder. Definitely planning on repurchasing and trying out the clear one for my eyebrows since a lot of people have been recommending it to me.